CRI Home - Photo- Forums - Talk China - Surf China - About China -  
  Webcast | CRI Today | China | World | Biz | SciTech | Sports | Life | Showbiz | Easy FM | Learn Chinese / English | Weather | Events
 
 
 
 
Old Japan Meets Hollywood in "Geisha"
2005-12-08 10:14:23      Reuters
The makers of "Memoirs of a Geisha" say it's a Hollywood love letter to a lost Japan, but ahead of its Friday opening the movie has generated mixed reviews and complaints about cultural insensitivities.

Based on a blockbuster book by Arthur Golden that sold four million copies, the movie followed a long, tortured path to the big screen. The finished product is an American film about Japan's colorful ladies of the night played by Chinese actors and filmed entirely in California.   

Early reviews have been generally favorable.   

"Japan has always had an appreciation of Hollywood magic," producer Douglas Wick said in an interview. "Some of the very best Hollywood craft people have created this love letter to a lost Japanese world."   

Wick said the movie is not a historical documentary on the geisha culture but an effort to tell a "universal love story" that will appeal to international audiences.   

But during promotional appearances in Japan ahead of the movie's launch, the film's makers encountered criticism over its authenticity and its non-Japanese stars.   

"We were aware of the cultural sensitivities," said Wick, who produced the film with his wife Lucy Fisher and Steven Spielberg.

But Wick insists that he found "broad acceptance and enthusiasm for the movie" that far outweighed any gripes.   

ART OF THE GEISHA   

Wick said he spent eight years on the project and spoke with more than two dozen directors before hiring Rob Marshall, fresh from the Oscar-winning "Chicago." His vision was a movie that emphasized lavish sets and the art of the geisha.   

"Geisha" opens in New York and Japan this weekend on a limited number of screens.   

Wick hopes his big-budget movie, estimated to have cost $80 million, does better than the book did in Japan, where its American authorship gave it limited appeal.   

Its acceptance there was also marred by a much-publicized lawsuit by Mineko Iwasaki, the geisha whose life story inspired the book, over the use of her name and factual differences.   

In the movie, the main roles are played by Chinese actors who have recently made international hits, fanning criticism in both countries.   

Ziyi Zhang, who plays the blue-eyed geisha Sayuri, was the star of the much-acclaimed breakthrough hit, "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" -- a source of much pride for China's film industry. But her portrayal of a Japanese women has produced mixed feelings in China, where resentment at Japan for its past military aggression runs strong.   

"She's sold her soul and betrayed her country. Hacking her to death would not be good enough," China's state media quoted one blogger as saying.   

One U.S. critic, in The Village Voice, saw problems with the film's handling of cultural issues, calling it "deluxe Orientalist kitsch."   Cultural Anthropology professor Anne Allison of Duke University said: "It's a problem in that it's Westerners viewing all of Asia as the same. It kind of confirms that it's less a movie about Japan and more a movie about The Orient."   



        Talk China        Print        Email        Recommend
  Copyright of crienglish.com. All rights reserved.

Reproduction of text for non-commercial purposes is permitted provided that both the source and author are acknowledged and a notifying email is sent to us.
 
 
• Can Celebrity Appear in Commercials?
• "Judgment in Tokyo" Opens in May
• Music Festival Feasting Ears of Shanghai Citizens
• "Hostage"---A-mei
• Black and White Movie
• A-mei's New Song "I Want Happiness"
  • The Da Vinci Code Deciphered

  • "The Da Vinci Code" has finally been deciphered by world audiences this week.
  • World Carnival 2006

  • This year's "world carnival" is coming to Beijing, but with a different Italian style.
  • Holiday Guide

  • CRI Entertainment sorts out some available options for whom choose to stay in Beijing. Enjoy your long holiday.  
  • China-India Friendship Year

  • The year 2006 has been designated as the China-India Friendship Year.
  • Spring Movie Map

  • CRI Entertainment collects some this spring's new movies for you
  • 25th HK Film Awards

  • The Hong Kong's annual Oscar was unveiled on April 8th. Winners
  • The Oscar Goes to ... Ang Lee!

  • The Oscar winning director became a hot topic in China...
  • 78th Academy Awards

  • The annual Oscar nominations will be announced on January 31.
     
    [an error occurred while processing this directive]